Whether it would be a good AMA if it were fulfilled. See above for those qualities
Whether the OP could provide proof if it were fulfilled. Often requests are posted for things that would be impossible to verify. You can also make more specific requests: for example, instead of “AMA request, a murderer” you could request “AMA, someone who has been convicted of murder,” because then they would have court documents as proof.
How likely it is that an AMA would happen. Generally, requesting one specific person is difficult, but you can improve your chances by providing a way to contact that person, like their twitter account. Requests are more likely to be fulfilled if you’re requesting a group of people rather than just one in particular
Upvote requests which have included at least 5 questions which are relevant to the person being requested. If these are not present, please report the post and message the mods!